Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes

Date: October 21, 2026

Topic: Site operations — post-filing contacts, rejects, returns on hold, and the taxpayer experience after the visit

Session Overview

  • Open-floor “what’s on your mind” discussion, followed by the last of the site operations discussions: how programs contact taxpayers after a reject, what happens to returns put on hold for missing documentation, and what taxpayers take away from the experience.
  • Seven participants spoke alongside the facilitator; more may have attended without speaking.

Notes are generated with AI assistance and anonymized before publishing — participant names, organizations, and locations are left out below. Software and public resources mentioned by name are kept in for reference.

What’s on Your Mind? Updates from the Field

  • Success: after about three years of pursuing it, one participant’s program was confirmed as a partner of a community college. The participant will attend classes beginning in December; the department director’s exact ask (recruiting, informing, or offering opportunities) is not yet clear. The college is offering a tax class for the first time and was described as very responsive to local needs, able to create certification classes quickly. The facilitator suggested community college systems in other states may be a similar resource.
  • Request: a participant expanding a virtual team asked for site-coordinator-specific online or recorded training beyond the IRS videos, for new coordinators at site extensions who cannot attend the in-person (or even virtual) coordinator training.
  • Resources suggested: a VITA practitioner’s whole-site training that one participant had used as a study resource a couple of years ago (they will search their archives); Get Your Refund, which usually has good tools though maybe not a training; and a United Way program’s virtual VITA toolkit, which is somewhat dated but is the basis for much of Get Your Refund’s design.
  • The participant already records live virtual sessions, but discussion makes the recordings long, and audio with many voices is a problem. Facilitator’s suggestions: practice the presentation and record it, then deliver the class live and record again, using whichever is the cleanest take; and plan stopping points (for example, record in roughly 5-minute segments) so a section can be re-recorded rather than the whole thing. Coordinators likely also need content unique to the program, which favors making your own.

Communicating with Taxpayers After a Reject

  • One site: the site coordinator or a quality reviewer calls, and the contact is noted in TaxSlayer. If the number is out of order or rings unanswered, they email or mail a letter when possible and try calling again later. Missing IP PINs are the hardest cases.
  • Facilitator emphasized capturing multiple ways to reach a taxpayer: a phone number, a second contact number, email, and the mailing address already needed for the return.
  • Waiting for acceptance: one program, when space allows, asks clients to stay about 10–15 minutes until the return is “accepted for processing by the IRS,” using those exact words. Clients are told when the appointment is scheduled and again before preparation starts, and most are receptive. Most rejects can be resolved on the spot, even a missing IP PIN (for example, helping the client set up an IRS account or call for information from a Form 1095-A). A client who insists they have no IP PIN gets a paper return to mail. Acceptance takes about 20 minutes in February and 10–15 minutes later in the season (federal only). For clients who leave, texts get better responses than email. Another program used the wait-for-acceptance approach only at the end of the season.
  • Facilitator’s take: a clever solution to a common problem that gets rejects resolved quickly. It also creates time for additional services such as financial empowerment or voter registration checks. Think through whether your waiting area can handle it and whether clients leaving is actually a problem for your population.
  • One participant believed the tax software can text clients an acceptance notice if the phone number is on record and consents are signed, and wondered whether it also sends rejection notices; this was not confirmed.
  • An appointment-only program texts rejected clients through its scheduling software, since clients already trust that number, and also calls and leaves voicemail from a burner phone. Because the burner number changes each season, they text first asking clients to accept a call from the new number.
  • One small site has a single, most experienced person who files all of the day’s returns at the end of the day and follows up on rejects. Everyone in the office knows to send questions and callers to her. She keeps rejects together in one clipped packet with research notes, and prints returns for mailing so clients sign before leaving. Facilitator: usually one person handles this, but at least two people should know what’s happening with e-file (the “hit-by-a-bus” theory of VITA management) without too many hands in the process.
  • Outgoing phone numbers: Google Voice; online phone systems where all sites share one number and each has its own mailbox; burner phones; and one program that registers its main number and all extensions in the caller directory, labeled as free tax prep, so calls don’t show up as spam.
  • A year-round program has site coordinators track their own rejects and follow up about once a month during the summer, noting each attempt in TaxSlayer. If there is no response by the end of summer, the intake sheet is shredded and a note is left in TaxSlayer, since the status of a rejected return can’t be changed other than to paper.

Returns on Hold: Missing Documentation

  • The facilitator clarified the question: taxpayers whose return is partly done or at quality review when a W-2 or other documentation (for example, gambling records) turns out to be missing and they must go get it.
  • One program returns the documents to the taxpayer, notes it in TaxSlayer, and offers a follow-up appointment. For those who disappear, they check the software for in-progress returns from the last four weeks and call about once a week; if there’s no response, the return is converted to paper. They plan to add a template letter this coming season telling the taxpayer the return has not been completed and that completing it is now their responsibility.
  • Another program gives clients a packet with a checklist of what to bring and has seen problems drop from roughly 6 in 10 clients to about a third. The participant is considering texting the checklist ahead of appointments (using consents already collected and a bulk-text tool), noting that entering the numbers is an extra job at the end of the season, though a good one for an intern or volunteer.
  • Facilitator uses a simpler what-to-bring list from the CFPB, updated last year, because the IRS list names many items most taxpayers don’t have; it will be made available.
  • Facilitator’s practice: keep copies, not originals, in a taxpayer’s file. Whether to keep a file at all depends on your taxpayers, volunteers, and storage (for example, whether everything is locked away each night).

Surveys & Referrals

  • Surveys: one program must survey clients for some of its funding. Paper surveys are completed on site, framed as customer-service feedback, and pulled from the file to stay anonymous; a year using QR codes sharply reduced participation. Another site hands out a paper survey while the return is printing, with a survey box at the exit; they’re reviewed weekly and passed to management. One participant asked if anyone had used a tablet; no one on the call had.
  • Referrals: programs described referring clients to financial empowerment coaching and health insurance navigators, with weekly on-site availability and referrals given ahead of the visit so partners can call clients.
  • Facilitator: use a Form 7216 consent for referrals even when they’re in-house, and consider including follow-up on the referral among the things the taxpayer consents to. Follow-up matters more when referring to a community partner; have some way to check that the process is working.

The Taxpayer Experience

  • Facilitator’s framing: taxpayers may think “these dummies screwed up my return” when called about a reject; the goal is for them to think the program is responsive. Setting expectations up front helps — the IRS rejects returns for reasons beyond a site’s control, and the taxpayer should expect a call or text and know how it will come.
  • When to contact the site about a refund: one program says 4–6 weeks; another gives a quarter-sheet with “Where’s My Refund” information for federal and state; the facilitator says 3 weeks. Direct-deposit refunds typically arrive in 10–14 days, with state refunds longer; participants noted multi-week state delays in some states.
  • One participant who uses a personal cell phone for reject calls was repeatedly contacted by a client whose refund took about six weeks and arrived larger than filed. Facilitator guessed an IRS correction was made on the back end.
  • Facilitator prefers taxpayers contact the program when something is wrong, a habit that goes back to the early e-file days when federal returns were e-filed but state returns were mailed on paper and some clients never sent them. A participant noted a similar problem when clients owing money left their payment in the envelope instead of sending it.

Challenge of the Week: Prior-Year Returns and Missing Retirement Funds

  • A participant described a client in a year-round program who needed three prior years prepared. Digging in, the preparer found roughly $325,000 withdrawn from a retirement account in one year and more than $500,000 over two years, with no record of where it went. The client is the guardian of her husband and says she knew nothing; the preparer has begun to suspect she is not being fully upfront. The client has been told she will owe a lot but still wants the returns prepared.
  • Facilitator’s strong suggestion: bring in a Low Income Taxpayer Clinic (LITC) before filing; they can say whether to prepare the returns first and may have investigative tools and contacts. The client may also need a traditional legal clinic for guardianship and finances.
  • Other participants had seen similar cases: obtaining transcripts (including through a local IRS office) to see all transactions, and working with the bank to trace deposits. To find a clinic, search IRS.gov for “Low Income Taxpayer Clinic” or “Taxpayer Advocate Service” and look by state.
  • Facilitator noted that what used to be a first-time penalty forgiveness request is now automatic, starting this summer, and likely tied to the first return filed — so make sure it lands on the right return when clients have multiple years.
  • A participant described a client who owed about $20,000 for 2017–2020, half of it interest and fees, after her late husband, who had dementia, stopped paying. They had filed jointly, so the debt remained. Transcripts helped her understand when and why it happened, and the clinic was valuable for negotiating. Facilitator: clinics can pursue options such as innocent spouse relief, and taxpayers should not be afraid of working out a problem because the IRS has many tools for doing so.

Resources & Next Steps

  • The facilitator showed the free resources folder (a Dropbox folder linked from the website), including materials from a VITACon workshop with packets and guidance for running your own version, a free online sources section (including a virtual VITA toolkit and a nonresident tax help group’s resources), and links to another contributor’s resources. Participants are welcome to use and adapt any of it.
  • Next week: a snapshot discussion on volunteer recruitment — what people are doing right now and what low-hanging fruit might reach a few more volunteers.

The Society for Free Tax Assistance  •  VITAquality.org  •  a project of JC Craig Consulting

Comment on REG-119882-25: IRS Proposal to Restrict Refundable Tax Credits Based on Immigration Status

JC Craig of JC Craig Consulting submits this comment concerning REG-119882-25, RIN 1545-BS06, Docket No. IRS-2026-1057, Application of the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996 (PRWORA) to the Refunded Portion of Certain Federal Refundable Tax Credits.

Interest of the commenter

I have volunteered with the IRS Volunteer Income Tax Assistance (VITA) program for 25 years and prepared returns for thousands of low- and moderate-income taxpayers, including many mixed-status families. I have also developed and led training for volunteer preparers, providing technical assistance to organizations offering VITA service nationwide. I have served as a volunteer liaison between VITA/TCE practitioners and the IRS through the Security Summit and as a member of the IRS Electronic Tax Administration Advisory Committee (ETAAC) from 2017 to 2019. These comments reflect my experience as both a preparer and a leader in this field.

The proposed regulations should be withdrawn

These proposed regulations are poor tax administration. They would direct the IRS’s limited compliance, taxpayer-service, and legal resources toward an eligibility question with no documented history of erroneous claims or fraud, while leaving unaddressed the two problems the agency’s own data identifies as the actual drivers of improper payments on the refunded portion of these credits, discussed below. I urge the Department of the Treasury and the IRS to withdraw proposed §§ 1.23-2, 1.24-3, 1.25A-7, and 1.32-4 in their entirety.

As proposed, these regulations would apply PRWORA’s “qualified alien” test to the refunded portion of the adoption credit, the Child Tax Credit (through the Additional Child Tax Credit), the American Opportunity Tax Credit, and the Earned Income Tax Credit. Treasury’s own regulatory analysis estimates that, of the 24 million taxpayers expected to claim the refunded portion of these credits for tax year 2026, between 200,000 and 700,000 would become ineligible under the proposed rule, disallowing between $0.7 billion and $2.6 billion in refundable credits.

Whatever one thinks of the underlying immigration policy, a change of this magnitude should not rest on reinterpreting a 1996 welfare statute that Treasury and the IRS did not previously believe applied to the refunded portion of these credits. As the preamble itself acknowledges, “[p]rior to 2018, the Treasury Department and the IRS had not viewed tax benefits, including refundable credits, as constituting Federal public benefits under PRWORA.” That view changed only after the Office of Legal Counsel revisited the question in a 2020 opinion and reaffirmed it in a November 19, 2025 opinion, citing Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, 603 U.S. 369 (2024), as grounds to revisit the earlier reading. Loper Bright means a court reviewing this rule will not defer to Treasury’s interpretation merely because it is reasonable; the court must decide independently whether it is the single best reading of PRWORA. If this interpretation is genuinely the best reading of a statute enacted in 1996, it is difficult to explain why Treasury and the IRS held the contrary view for the next twenty-two years, and why it took two Office of Legal Counsel opinions over five years to arrive at it. If Congress intended the refunded portion of these four credits to be governed by PRWORA’s alien-eligibility categories, it has had roughly thirty years to say so in the Internal Revenue Code itself.

The proposal creates an administrability problem the current statute already avoids

Congress has already written an objective, verifiable eligibility test into three of the four affected credits, tied to whether the taxpayer (and, for the Child Tax Credit, the qualifying child) has a valid, work-eligible Social Security number:

  • Section 32 requires an SSN issued by the Social Security Administration, not one issued solely to receive a federally funded benefit;
  • Section 24(h)(7), applicable to taxable years beginning after December 31, 2024, requires a work-eligible SSN for the qualifying child and for the taxpayer (or at least one spouse on a joint return); and
  • Section 25A requires a work-eligible SSN before the return’s due date.

Congress revisited the Child Tax Credit’s SSN requirement as recently as the 2024 filing-year statutory change and chose not to layer a separate PRWORA “qualified alien” determination on top of it. The proposed regulations would nonetheless impose exactly that additional test — one that turns not on a verifiable Social Security Administration data field, but on an immigration classification that does not appear on any IRS form and that preparers have no reliable way to confirm.

The adoption credit contains no SSN-based or immigration-status eligibility requirement; it requires only that the taxpayer report the adopted child’s name, age, and taxpayer identification number. Proposed § 1.23-2 would create the only immigration-status eligibility gate anywhere in section 23 — not by implementing a term Congress used, but by grafting PRWORA onto a credit Congress never conditioned on immigration status.

The proposed regulations compound this problem by creating a new timing rule solely for immigration status, layered onto credits whose existing eligibility tests already have their own timing rules — a work-eligible SSN by the return’s due date, for example. The preamble states that each taxpayer must be a U.S. citizen, U.S. national, or qualified alien “on the date of filing an initial or amended Federal income tax return first claiming the credit for the taxable year,” reasoning that “the date on which the taxpayer first claims the credit is the most appropriate date” because, in the preamble’s own words, “the nonrefundable and refundable portions of a single credit cannot be claimed at different times.” In practice, this locks in a taxpayer’s qualified-alien status as of whenever they first file a return claiming the credit at all — including the nonrefundable portion, which most taxpayers claim regardless of PRWORA status. A taxpayer who is not yet a qualified alien on that date has no apparent path to recover the refundable portion later by amending once their status changes, even within the ordinary three-year period to file a refund claim under 26 U.S.C. § 6511(a), because the preamble treats the two portions of the same credit as impossible to claim at different times. Eligibility for these credits is already fully established by existing law; immigration status, to the extent it is tested at all, should determine only whether an already-earned refund can be paid, based on the taxpayer’s status whenever they properly file a claim — not on whichever return happened to be the first to mention the credit. No other eligibility requirement for the refunded portion of these credits works this way, and administering a filing-date-dependent test will require new systems logic, forms, and preparer training devoted to a distinction the current statute does not draw. It also creates an incentive to delay filing altogether: a taxpayer expecting to become a qualified alien later may choose to wait rather than file on time and forfeit the refundable portion permanently — the opposite of the timely compliance the tax system depends on.

In my VITA experience, the portion of a credit that reduces tax liability and the portion that is refunded have always been calculated the same way, using the same eligibility test, on the same line of the same form. The proposed regulations would require preparers to apply two different eligibility standards to two slices of a single credit on a single return: the existing statutory SSN test for one slice, and an unverifiable, date-locked immigration classification for the other.

Identity theft and falsely claimed dependents — not immigration status — are the documented fraud risks in these credits

To the extent the proposed regulations are meant to protect the refunded portion of these credits from fraud, they target the wrong risk. The IRS’s own reporting identifies two dominant sources of improper claims: unintentional errors relating to the qualifying-child residency test, and intentional fraud involving stolen identities and falsely or duplicately claimed dependents. Neither is caused by, or meaningfully addressed by, a taxpayer’s immigration status.

On the unintentional-error side, Treasury’s own analysts attribute most EITC overclaims to the qualifying-child residency requirement — whether a child lived with the taxpayer for more than half the year — in part because the IRS receives no administrative data to verify where a child resided. In my experience, taxpayers responding to IRS disallowances struggle to find documentation showing a child lived with them for the required time, because children are generally not listed on leases or mortgages.

On the fraud side, the dominant and well-documented risk is identity theft: a return filed using a stolen Social Security number, or a child claimed by someone before the legitimate taxpayer files. A Treasury Inspector General for Tax Administration report issued in May 2026 found that the IRS stopped roughly $7 billion in fraudulent refunds tied to identity theft in calendar years 2024 and 2025 alone — out of 7.5 million returns flagged by the IRS’s identity-theft filters over that period. That same report found that a substantial share of the flagged returns, roughly half in each of the two most recent years reviewed, actually belonged to legitimate taxpayers whose refunds were delayed while they proved who they were. That is the real administrability trade-off this rulemaking should be weighed against: a screening system that already produces large numbers of false positives among legitimate filers, now paired with a second, harder-to-verify eligibility test layered on top of it.

The IRS already has a targeted response to the false-dependent problem, and it has nothing to do with immigration status. Beginning with the 2025 filing season, the IRS started accepting electronically filed returns claiming a dependent who was already claimed on another return, provided the legitimate taxpayer includes a valid Identity Protection PIN — resolving in minutes an issue that previously required paper filing and months of delay. Where no IP PIN is available, the IRS’s existing process requires the legitimate taxpayer to paper-file, wait for the agency to contact both filers (typically around two months after filing), and then substantiate the claim with documentation such as birth certificates and proof that the child lived at the taxpayer’s address for more than half the year. Immigration status plays no role anywhere in that process, because it has no bearing on whether a dependent claim is fraudulent.

Layering a PRWORA “qualified alien” determination onto this system closes neither documented gap: it does not help the IRS verify where a child lived, and it does not help the IRS or preparers detect a stolen identity or a duplicated dependent claim. It only adds a third, unconnected eligibility question that will consume examination and taxpayer-service resources without addressing either of the fraud and error patterns the agency has actually documented.

The required declaration carries felony exposure for an honest mistake

The proposed regulations would require every taxpayer claiming the refunded portion of one of these credits to sign, under penalty of perjury, a declaration that they are a U.S. citizen, U.S. national, or qualified alien eligible to receive the credit. The preamble is explicit about the stakes: it cites 26 U.S.C. § 7206, which makes willfully providing false information on a return a felony punishable by a fine of up to $100,000 and up to three years in prison; 18 U.S.C. § 1015(e), which separately makes a knowing false claim of citizenship or national status a felony; and 18 U.S.C. § 1001, which makes a knowing and willful false statement to the federal government a felony.

Asking taxpayers to certify their own PRWORA status under threat of felony prosecution assumes that status is simple to determine. It is not. The Office of Legal Counsel itself took two opinions and roughly five years to settle how PRWORA applies to these credits. VITA volunteers and paid preparers alike will now be asking taxpayers, many of whom have never heard the term “qualified alien” and cannot readily classify their own status against the eight categories in 8 U.S.C. § 1641(b), to attest to that classification under oath. A taxpayer who guesses wrong in good faith, or who is misled by someone else, has signed the same felony declaration a person who lied deliberately would have signed. The absence of a verification method cuts both ways: the same uncertainty that puts an honest taxpayer at risk of an unwitting false declaration gives a dishonest preparer or filer confidence that a false declaration will not be caught.

I recommend that the final rule state expressly that a good-faith, non-willful error in this declaration will not be treated as a violation of 26 U.S.C. § 7206, 18 U.S.C. § 1001, or 18 U.S.C. § 1015(e), and will not be referred for criminal investigation absent evidence that the taxpayer actually knew the declaration was false. Without that assurance, this requirement will not just deter accurate filing by eligible and ineligible taxpayers alike — it will generate additional correspondence, disputes, and taxpayer-service contacts for the IRS to resolve, on top of a verification burden the agency’s own data does not show is necessary.

The rule will cause eligible taxpayers to forgo refundable credits, without a workable way to catch the taxpayers it targets

I have repeatedly encountered taxpayers who conflate PRWORA benefit eligibility with the separate “public charge” inadmissibility test under INA § 212(a)(4). Even though the two are legally distinct, the confusion is real, and it changes behavior. Research on the 2019 public charge rule found that one in five adults in immigrant families with children (20.4 percent) reported avoiding public benefits altogether because of immigration-related fear or confusion — even though tax credits were not among the programs targeted by that rule. There is every reason to expect a comparable chilling effect here, this time affecting U.S. citizen children whose parents are uncertain about their own status or simply afraid of making a mistake.

The eligibility test also attaches to the wrong person. Under the proposed regulations, it is the filer’s own status — not the qualifying child’s — that determines whether the refunded portion of the Child Tax Credit is paid. A U.S. citizen child, whose own eligibility Congress addressed directly in section 24(h)(7), can lose access to that credit’s refundable value entirely because of a parent’s immigration classification that has nothing to do with the child’s own citizenship. Congress did not write the Child Tax Credit’s SSN requirement this way; it tested the child’s and the taxpayer’s own SSN status, not a separate immigration classification of the parent.

Paid preparers, meanwhile, face due-diligence obligations under 26 U.S.C. § 6695(g): a penalty, currently $650 per failure for 2026 returns (up to $2,600 if a single return involves all four credits), for failing to adequately determine a taxpayer’s eligibility for the EITC, CTC/ACTC/ODC, AOTC, or head-of-household status. Without a verifiable method to confirm “qualified alien” status, preparers are left to choose between declining to prepare returns for taxpayers they cannot definitively clear — denying eligible taxpayers a credit they are entitled to — or relying on the taxpayer’s own representation and risking a penalty if that representation later proves wrong through no fault of the preparer. As a VITA preparer, I rely on the taxpayer’s own representation for every other eligibility question on a return; there is no reason PRWORA status should be different, yet unlike every other eligibility fact a taxpayer represents, it now carries the felony exposure described above.

The regulation invites costly, resource-intensive litigation over an unresolved legal question

Even apart from the concerns above, finalizing this rule is likely to draw exactly the kind of prolonged, multi-front litigation that consumes the same scarce IRS and Treasury resources this comment describes elsewhere, without producing a lasting result. As discussed above, Loper Bright eliminated the deference courts previously gave agencies interpreting ambiguous statutes; a reviewing court must now decide independently whether Treasury’s reading of PRWORA is the single best reading of the statute, not merely a reasonable one. That is a harder standard to meet, particularly given that Treasury and the IRS took the opposite position for twenty-two years before 2018.

This rule also has the features that have drawn sustained legal challenge to other agency actions in recent years: a claim of new authority over a matter of substantial economic and political significance — hundreds of thousands of taxpayers, billions of dollars — based on reinterpreting a statute other than the one the agency ordinarily administers. The closest precedent is the 2019 public charge rule, which was challenged within weeks in federal courts across multiple states, produced conflicting rulings and preliminary injunctions, and was ultimately rescinded before the underlying legal question was resolved on the merits, after years of litigation cost to the government.

If this rule follows a similar path, the IRS should expect to defend it simultaneously in multiple courts while also building the implementation — new forms, systems changes, preparer guidance, and examination procedures — that a nationwide injunction could freeze or unwind at any point. That is a substantial commitment of the same limited legal, compliance, and administrative resources this comment describes elsewhere, spent on a rule that may never take lasting effect, in an area where the agency has not identified a documented compliance problem to justify the expenditure.

Recommendations

If the Department and the IRS do not withdraw the proposed regulations, I recommend, at minimum:

  1. Remove the adoption credit (proposed § 1.23-2) from the rule’s scope, since section 23 contains no immigration-status eligibility test Congress enacted for the IRS to implement.
  2. Do not create a separate timing rule for qualified-alien status. Eligibility for these credits is already fully established by the existing work-eligible SSN test; immigration status, if retained at all, should determine only whether the refundable portion can be paid, based on the taxpayer’s status whenever they properly claim it — including by filing an amended return within the normal refund limitations period under 26 U.S.C. § 6511(a) if their status changes after their original filing.
  3. Publish the specific, auditable method the IRS and preparers are expected to use to verify “qualified alien” status, or state plainly that the rule will rely on taxpayer self-certification alone.
  4. Provide education to taxpayers regarding specific statuses that are not eligible for refundable portions of tax credits, with clear directions on how to get more information. In that outreach and education, make clear that affected taxpayers remain eligible to use the credits to reduce tax liability.
  5. Confirm, in the final rule, that VITA/TCE volunteer preparers and paid preparers satisfy their due-diligence obligations under 26 U.S.C. § 6695(g) by relying on a taxpayer’s valid, work-eligible SSN, without independently verifying immigration classification.
  6. State expressly that a good-faith, non-willful error in the required declaration will not be treated as a violation of 26 U.S.C. § 7206, 18 U.S.C. § 1001, or 18 U.S.C. § 1015(e), and will not be referred for criminal investigation absent evidence of actual knowledge of ineligibility.
  7. Provide a reasonable-cause cure period, rather than automatic disallowance or preparer penalty, when a good-faith declaration later proves incorrect.
  8. Delay the applicability date beyond “taxable years ending on or after” the final rule’s publication, to give the IRS, tax software providers, and preparers at least one full filing season of lead time.
  9. Before finalizing the rule, address how Treasury and the IRS intend to prevent the kind of chilling effect documented after the 2019 public charge rule, which caused eligible U.S. citizen family members to forgo benefits out of fear or confusion unrelated to their actual eligibility.
  10. If Treasury and the IRS retain a fraud-prevention rationale for this rule, explain in the final rule how the proposed eligibility test improves on the identity-verification tools already in use, such as the IP PIN process for duplicate dependent claims, since immigration status is not a factor in either of the documented error and fraud patterns — qualifying-child residency and identity theft — that the IRS itself has identified as the primary drivers of improper payments on the refunded portion of these credits.
  11. Consistent with the cost-benefit analysis Executive Orders 12866 and 13563 already require, publish an estimate that accounts for implementation, examination, taxpayer-service, and reasonably anticipated litigation-defense costs, and weigh that estimate against the absence of documented evidence that immigration status is a meaningful driver of improper payments on the refunded portion of these credits.

Conclusion

The refundable credits at issue already have workable, statutorily defined eligibility rules that VITA volunteers, paid preparers, and the IRS itself rely on every filing season. The proposed regulations would replace that clear standard with a second, harder-to-verify test grafted onto a 1996 statute that Treasury and the IRS did not previously apply to the refunded portion of these credits, for reasons that, by the preamble’s own account, trace to two recent OLC opinions rather than any change Congress made to the Internal Revenue Code. Every time Treasury reinterprets a non-Code statute to change tax administration in this way, it invites a future administration to do the same for unrelated purposes — for example, to revisit eligibility for corporate or high-income tax provisions through a similarly creative reading of some other federal statute, rather than through legislation. Doing so is not only legally vulnerable; it is poor use of the IRS’s limited resources at a moment when those resources are better spent on the credits’ documented sources of error and fraud. I respectfully urge the Department and the IRS to withdraw the proposed regulations or, at minimum, adopt the changes described above before finalizing them.

Respectfully submitted,

JC Craig

JC Craig Consulting

johncharlescraig@gmail.com

Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes

Date: September 23, 2026

Topic: Quality review — reviewer tools and support, and the taxpayer’s experience of return review

Session Overview

  • Open-floor “what’s on your mind” discussion, followed by the planned topic: the taxpayer’s experience of return review and the tools reviewers use beyond IRS-provided materials.
  • Notes are generated with AI assistance and anonymized before publishing — participant names and identifying program details are left out. Products and public resources mentioned by name are kept in for reference.

What’s on Your Mind

  • Grants: A participant asked whether anyone had news of the VITA-support grant from Wells Fargo, separate from the Citi Foundation child savings support grants that Prosperity Now had just announced. Another participant noted the Wells Fargo announcement is not due until September 29th; the facilitator agreed announcements are getting close.
  • Certifying Acceptance Agents (CAA): The facilitator was asked for suggestions for people pursuing CAA status. A participant noted the IRS is no longer offering forensic document training; the outside provider their program used cost roughly $150. The facilitator encouraged everyone to consider becoming a CAA — assisting with the ITIN application is a major benefit to taxpayers who need it, and many paid preparers charge quite a bit for it. Taxpayers may also struggle to use Taxpayer Assistance Center offices, which can involve ID requirements to enter the building and offices located in buildings that also house immigration enforcement. Taxpayers trust their VITA preparers, and being able to get this help from them is a comfort.
  • Proposed IRS regulation: The facilitator flagged new regulations published in the Federal Register that change requirements for immigrant taxpayers claiming credits — only the refundable portion of a credit would be affected, and eligibility would no longer rest on a work-eligible Social Security card. Their concern is less the taxpayers who lose eligibility than the many who remain eligible but must now sort out how public-charge and public-benefit rules apply, leaving preparers unsure how much to rely on a taxpayer’s own assurances under due diligence. The facilitator views this as poor tax administration, noted the IRS lacks a strong enforcement mechanism (so honest, confused taxpayers are likelier to lose credits than those who would cheat anyway), and said the effort would be better spent on unscrupulous preparers and identity theft.
  • Commenting: Anyone can comment to the Federal Register; comments are due October 5th and can be short (for example, a VITA preparer’s view that they joined to keep people tax compliant, not to determine immigration status). A participant noted long comments may intimidate some volunteers. The facilitator will share their own comments with the listserv and likely post them on VITAQuality.org, and others are free to reuse any of it. The facilitator also noted that VITA volunteers are not currently subject to the paid-preparer EITC due diligence requirements, including the associated form.

Tools Reviewers Use Beyond IRS Materials

  • One program developed a quality review desk guide, rolled out last year, aimed at newer reviewers. Long-time volunteers and managers considered it a waste of time, so the program clarified it is not written for them and does slow things down, but believes it has helped get new reviewers up to speed. The same program also borrowed another program’s self-employment worksheet.
  • The facilitator observed that VITA programs freely borrow and iterate on each other’s materials — sometimes finding a heavily improved version of something they wrote years ago — which is a key reason for keeping this community going. Checklists remain useful even for experienced reviewers, particularly at the start of the season.
  • A quality review training video series created some years ago (role-play style, originally built for an online training and later posted to YouTube by Prosperity Now) may still be available; the facilitator will try to track it down, while noting it is dated.
  • Tax Roundtable was named as a strong resource for complex questions. In a large metro program with highly credentialed volunteers, the facilitator noted the trade-off that experts unfamiliar with low-income returns can find them a new experience.

How Reviewers Get Questions Answered

  • The facilitator described larger sites with a group of reviewers plus a lead reviewer, sometimes on-site and sometimes reachable by phone. Historically, hard questions were pulled in to experienced preparers while the return was put on hold, and questions from remote sites came by phone or email chain.
  • One program tried a person dedicated solely to quality review this past season to keep clients moving in and out on time. That person may be an experienced preparer or the site coordinator, rotating between preparers as needed. The program uses both peer review and designated reviewers depending on site size and appointment slots. Another participant’s site coordinators are all experienced past preparers, so peer review is less of a concern.
  • The facilitator prefers designated reviewers because reviewers improve with repetition, but has not seen strong evidence that designated review beats peer review; many reviewers also want to prepare returns, and review must not become a bottleneck, since bottlenecks lead volunteers to work around the process.
  • Ideas for connecting people: a program wiki, a group chat or Slack-type channel for site coordinators (the facilitator noted having tried Slack too early and being against it at first), and other ways to reach experienced volunteers when a site is out of sight and has a question.

The Taxpayer’s Experience of Review

  • Participants reported that taxpayers are generally very happy that two people look at every return, especially when a reviewer catches something a preparer missed. One participant noted some returning clients ask not to work with a new preparer; they reassure clients that preparers are trained and certified and that help is nearby. This participant has not seen clients upset over a change during review in five years.
  • The facilitator said clients often glaze over during the process, that setting expectations about what happens and why is the main lever, and that VITA accuracy on EITC returns is far better than other preparers’ because of its focus on getting it right and its 100% quality review. Taxpayers themselves are important to review: most mistakes the facilitator has caught surfaced when a taxpayer answered a question differently than the preparer had recorded (for example, a full-time student living in the home who was missing from the intake sheet).
  • Refund display: The facilitator asked whether the running refund amount can be hidden in TaxSlayer; a participant was unsure how. One program seats clients across the table from the screen and withholds the refund number until quality review is complete, so clients aren’t disappointed if it changes. The facilitator dislikes watching taxpayers swing between excited and discouraged as the return is built, but likes clients seeing the screen to catch misspelled names.

Looking Ahead

  • Next session: volunteer management software. Two people are already scheduled to share their experiences, and a third presenter is welcome — Volunteer Hub, Volgistics, and Salesforce were named as common products. A key question is how large or complex a program must be to justify switching from a spreadsheet, since these systems take more technical skill to operate.
  • The facilitator thanked everyone for the strong turnout and will follow up with a participant about volunteer management software contacts.

The Society for Free Tax Assistance  •  VITAquality.org  •  a project of JC Craig Consulting