Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes

Date: October 21, 2026

Topic: Site operations — post-filing contacts, rejects, returns on hold, and the taxpayer experience after the visit

Session Overview

  • Open-floor “what’s on your mind” discussion, followed by the last of the site operations discussions: how programs contact taxpayers after a reject, what happens to returns put on hold for missing documentation, and what taxpayers take away from the experience.
  • Seven participants spoke alongside the facilitator; more may have attended without speaking.

Notes are generated with AI assistance and anonymized before publishing — participant names, organizations, and locations are left out below. Software and public resources mentioned by name are kept in for reference.

What’s on Your Mind? Updates from the Field

  • Success: after about three years of pursuing it, one participant’s program was confirmed as a partner of a community college. The participant will attend classes beginning in December; the department director’s exact ask (recruiting, informing, or offering opportunities) is not yet clear. The college is offering a tax class for the first time and was described as very responsive to local needs, able to create certification classes quickly. The facilitator suggested community college systems in other states may be a similar resource.
  • Request: a participant expanding a virtual team asked for site-coordinator-specific online or recorded training beyond the IRS videos, for new coordinators at site extensions who cannot attend the in-person (or even virtual) coordinator training.
  • Resources suggested: a VITA practitioner’s whole-site training that one participant had used as a study resource a couple of years ago (they will search their archives); Get Your Refund, which usually has good tools though maybe not a training; and a United Way program’s virtual VITA toolkit, which is somewhat dated but is the basis for much of Get Your Refund’s design.
  • The participant already records live virtual sessions, but discussion makes the recordings long, and audio with many voices is a problem. Facilitator’s suggestions: practice the presentation and record it, then deliver the class live and record again, using whichever is the cleanest take; and plan stopping points (for example, record in roughly 5-minute segments) so a section can be re-recorded rather than the whole thing. Coordinators likely also need content unique to the program, which favors making your own.

Communicating with Taxpayers After a Reject

  • One site: the site coordinator or a quality reviewer calls, and the contact is noted in TaxSlayer. If the number is out of order or rings unanswered, they email or mail a letter when possible and try calling again later. Missing IP PINs are the hardest cases.
  • Facilitator emphasized capturing multiple ways to reach a taxpayer: a phone number, a second contact number, email, and the mailing address already needed for the return.
  • Waiting for acceptance: one program, when space allows, asks clients to stay about 10–15 minutes until the return is “accepted for processing by the IRS,” using those exact words. Clients are told when the appointment is scheduled and again before preparation starts, and most are receptive. Most rejects can be resolved on the spot, even a missing IP PIN (for example, helping the client set up an IRS account or call for information from a Form 1095-A). A client who insists they have no IP PIN gets a paper return to mail. Acceptance takes about 20 minutes in February and 10–15 minutes later in the season (federal only). For clients who leave, texts get better responses than email. Another program used the wait-for-acceptance approach only at the end of the season.
  • Facilitator’s take: a clever solution to a common problem that gets rejects resolved quickly. It also creates time for additional services such as financial empowerment or voter registration checks. Think through whether your waiting area can handle it and whether clients leaving is actually a problem for your population.
  • One participant believed the tax software can text clients an acceptance notice if the phone number is on record and consents are signed, and wondered whether it also sends rejection notices; this was not confirmed.
  • An appointment-only program texts rejected clients through its scheduling software, since clients already trust that number, and also calls and leaves voicemail from a burner phone. Because the burner number changes each season, they text first asking clients to accept a call from the new number.
  • One small site has a single, most experienced person who files all of the day’s returns at the end of the day and follows up on rejects. Everyone in the office knows to send questions and callers to her. She keeps rejects together in one clipped packet with research notes, and prints returns for mailing so clients sign before leaving. Facilitator: usually one person handles this, but at least two people should know what’s happening with e-file (the “hit-by-a-bus” theory of VITA management) without too many hands in the process.
  • Outgoing phone numbers: Google Voice; online phone systems where all sites share one number and each has its own mailbox; burner phones; and one program that registers its main number and all extensions in the caller directory, labeled as free tax prep, so calls don’t show up as spam.
  • A year-round program has site coordinators track their own rejects and follow up about once a month during the summer, noting each attempt in TaxSlayer. If there is no response by the end of summer, the intake sheet is shredded and a note is left in TaxSlayer, since the status of a rejected return can’t be changed other than to paper.

Returns on Hold: Missing Documentation

  • The facilitator clarified the question: taxpayers whose return is partly done or at quality review when a W-2 or other documentation (for example, gambling records) turns out to be missing and they must go get it.
  • One program returns the documents to the taxpayer, notes it in TaxSlayer, and offers a follow-up appointment. For those who disappear, they check the software for in-progress returns from the last four weeks and call about once a week; if there’s no response, the return is converted to paper. They plan to add a template letter this coming season telling the taxpayer the return has not been completed and that completing it is now their responsibility.
  • Another program gives clients a packet with a checklist of what to bring and has seen problems drop from roughly 6 in 10 clients to about a third. The participant is considering texting the checklist ahead of appointments (using consents already collected and a bulk-text tool), noting that entering the numbers is an extra job at the end of the season, though a good one for an intern or volunteer.
  • Facilitator uses a simpler what-to-bring list from the CFPB, updated last year, because the IRS list names many items most taxpayers don’t have; it will be made available.
  • Facilitator’s practice: keep copies, not originals, in a taxpayer’s file. Whether to keep a file at all depends on your taxpayers, volunteers, and storage (for example, whether everything is locked away each night).

Surveys & Referrals

  • Surveys: one program must survey clients for some of its funding. Paper surveys are completed on site, framed as customer-service feedback, and pulled from the file to stay anonymous; a year using QR codes sharply reduced participation. Another site hands out a paper survey while the return is printing, with a survey box at the exit; they’re reviewed weekly and passed to management. One participant asked if anyone had used a tablet; no one on the call had.
  • Referrals: programs described referring clients to financial empowerment coaching and health insurance navigators, with weekly on-site availability and referrals given ahead of the visit so partners can call clients.
  • Facilitator: use a Form 7216 consent for referrals even when they’re in-house, and consider including follow-up on the referral among the things the taxpayer consents to. Follow-up matters more when referring to a community partner; have some way to check that the process is working.

The Taxpayer Experience

  • Facilitator’s framing: taxpayers may think “these dummies screwed up my return” when called about a reject; the goal is for them to think the program is responsive. Setting expectations up front helps — the IRS rejects returns for reasons beyond a site’s control, and the taxpayer should expect a call or text and know how it will come.
  • When to contact the site about a refund: one program says 4–6 weeks; another gives a quarter-sheet with “Where’s My Refund” information for federal and state; the facilitator says 3 weeks. Direct-deposit refunds typically arrive in 10–14 days, with state refunds longer; participants noted multi-week state delays in some states.
  • One participant who uses a personal cell phone for reject calls was repeatedly contacted by a client whose refund took about six weeks and arrived larger than filed. Facilitator guessed an IRS correction was made on the back end.
  • Facilitator prefers taxpayers contact the program when something is wrong, a habit that goes back to the early e-file days when federal returns were e-filed but state returns were mailed on paper and some clients never sent them. A participant noted a similar problem when clients owing money left their payment in the envelope instead of sending it.

Challenge of the Week: Prior-Year Returns and Missing Retirement Funds

  • A participant described a client in a year-round program who needed three prior years prepared. Digging in, the preparer found roughly $325,000 withdrawn from a retirement account in one year and more than $500,000 over two years, with no record of where it went. The client is the guardian of her husband and says she knew nothing; the preparer has begun to suspect she is not being fully upfront. The client has been told she will owe a lot but still wants the returns prepared.
  • Facilitator’s strong suggestion: bring in a Low Income Taxpayer Clinic (LITC) before filing; they can say whether to prepare the returns first and may have investigative tools and contacts. The client may also need a traditional legal clinic for guardianship and finances.
  • Other participants had seen similar cases: obtaining transcripts (including through a local IRS office) to see all transactions, and working with the bank to trace deposits. To find a clinic, search IRS.gov for “Low Income Taxpayer Clinic” or “Taxpayer Advocate Service” and look by state.
  • Facilitator noted that what used to be a first-time penalty forgiveness request is now automatic, starting this summer, and likely tied to the first return filed — so make sure it lands on the right return when clients have multiple years.
  • A participant described a client who owed about $20,000 for 2017–2020, half of it interest and fees, after her late husband, who had dementia, stopped paying. They had filed jointly, so the debt remained. Transcripts helped her understand when and why it happened, and the clinic was valuable for negotiating. Facilitator: clinics can pursue options such as innocent spouse relief, and taxpayers should not be afraid of working out a problem because the IRS has many tools for doing so.

Resources & Next Steps

  • The facilitator showed the free resources folder (a Dropbox folder linked from the website), including materials from a VITACon workshop with packets and guidance for running your own version, a free online sources section (including a virtual VITA toolkit and a nonresident tax help group’s resources), and links to another contributor’s resources. Participants are welcome to use and adapt any of it.
  • Next week: a snapshot discussion on volunteer recruitment — what people are doing right now and what low-hanging fruit might reach a few more volunteers.

The Society for Free Tax Assistance  •  VITAquality.org  •  a project of JC Craig Consulting

Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes

Date: September 30, 2026

Topic: Volunteer management software — three program walkthroughs, virtual volunteers, and links to client scheduling

Session Overview

  • Three presenters walked through the systems their programs use to recruit, schedule, and track volunteers, followed by open questions and discussion.
  • Notes are generated with AI assistance and anonymized before publishing — participant names and identifying program details are left out below. Organizations, software, and public resources mentioned by name are kept in for reference.

Salesforce (nonprofit add-on)

  • Why: The program previously used a website form that fed an Excel sheet wiped every year, so volunteers could not be tracked over time. It moved to a Salesforce add-on already used for donor tracking. Setup took substantial time.
  • Volunteer side: Two entry points, new or experienced (“experienced” simply means the person has already completed the registration form, even if they never volunteered). The form collects contact information, LinkedIn profile, company or school affiliation (for corporate outreach and student class credit), language skills, CPA status, emergency contact, and a checkbox acknowledging the volunteer handbook, which covers liability. Each volunteer gets a record and a personal dashboard to update their info, see upcoming shifts and history, and sign up from a calendar. Signing up triggers a confirmation email with the handbook and training video links, plus a reminder email, all pre-programmed.
  • Admin side: Customizable dashboard showing volunteers signed up, top volunteer hours, unique volunteers versus attendees (repeat visits), each opening a detailed report. Shifts list the job and location because volunteers often want a specific site. The program runs many locations, only one of which is a VITA site, all tracked in one database.
  • Check-in: Admins or site coordinators can add volunteers or log hours after the fact. On site, the site manager checks volunteers in on an iPad so nobody (e.g., student volunteers) is signed in by someone else; no-shows get no credit.
  • Build & cost: Built with pro bono help — volunteer programmers, college students, Salesforce employees, and Catchafire (which requires payment or a funder). Free but slow. Salesforce offers nonprofits 10 free user licenses through a certification process. Tip: make a call-out to your own volunteer base for someone with Salesforce experience. Drawback: a plain interface that is hard to customize.

Volunteer Local

  • Eight metro sites had outgrown Excel. Volunteer Local is simple and password-free: volunteers browse shifts, self-sign up, and can see who else is signed up (useful for volunteers who like working with a particular group). Admins search for a volunteer to see years of service, hours, and past, current, and canceled shifts.
  • Check-in: Volunteers check themselves in and out. For senior volunteers, a QR code built in Canva and printed as stickers is placed on each laptop so they can scan to check in. If someone forgets, an admin can check them out manually.
  • Features: Jobs and slots are adjustable by day, time, and role — e.g., off-season needs a site coordinator and three preparers; in season add a greeter, a second coordinator, and more preparers. Each job shows qualifications and duties. Filtering by certification is available (unused here, since all volunteers are advanced-certified). One-click emails everyone signed up for a shift (e.g., weather cancellations). Reports filter by site and job, and hours reporting went from “a nightmare” in Excel to “just a click.”
  • Plan & cost: The Discover (basic) plan is $600/year with unlimited features and two admin seats; hours and attendance tracking are included. Most sites are appointment-only, so shift sign-up counts are used to open taxpayer appointment slots in Waitwhile.

Moving Away from Get Connected (Galaxy Digital)

  • Where it fell short: Get Connected works reasonably well for smaller organizations or programs with fewer volunteers. This program had over 600 volunteers last year and is aiming for about 800, and found it very hard to manage them in such a basic system.
  • Specific problems: It could not link shifts together, took a very long time to load, and its reporting is just a raw dump of responses that then had to go into a pivot table. The training sign-up process could never be plugged into it, so the program ran training registration through a Microsoft Word/Forms setup with a lot of logic, and used Formstack for certificate uploads. The presenter called it “a huge mess” that had been tolerated for years without working.
  • The core requirement: The program does not want volunteers signing up for one-off or “onesie-twosie” shifts. It wants a commitment to the full 13-week tax season on a single fixed weekly slot (e.g., Tuesdays 12 to 4), with no choice of individual dates; if someone cannot do that slot for at least 8 or 10 of the 13 weeks, the program would rather they not volunteer. Many volunteer platforms instead show volunteers the whole menu of shifts and let them pick. Because Get Connected could not link shifts, the workaround was to create “dummy” shifts in which the first shift of the season stood in for the rest.
  • What drove the decision: The presenter had complained about Get Connected for years while cobbling together Get Connected responses, a Microsoft Form, and Formstack uploads. Volunteer management at the organization is essentially one person, who also creates most of the recruitment marketing material and is involved in hiring, so the workload with this many volunteers had become impossible to sustain. The inability to find software that linked shifts had been the “Achilles’ heel” of the search.
  • How it got approved: After finding Rosterfy, the presenter did roughly 18 to 20 hours of demos before feeling confident, then “ambushed” the IT department and pushed the purchase through. When asked by the facilitator how to win buy-in from leadership (CEO, CFO), the honest answer was “brute force” — years of pain and not letting anyone stop it.

Rosterfy

  • What it will hold: The program is moving everything into Rosterfy: the tax shifts (as events), volunteer training, and certification uploads tied to the volunteer agreement. Shifts can be linked, so signing up for one Tuesday signs a volunteer up for all of them.
  • Automation & permissions: Built-in automation that can be made very granular. Seasonal site managers can be added as “light admins,” with permissions set down to the detail — for example, view only certain forms, see only responses, read versus edit access, or see emails but not update them.
  • Data & reporting: Rosterfy saves data to the volunteer’s profile rather than to each form. Instead of pulling raw form responses and merging them with other Excel sheets, the program can build a custom report from any profile information — e.g., training registration responses plus each volunteer’s name and phone number — and save it as a report type to run whenever needed.
  • Groups: Volunteers can be placed automatically into multiple groups (e.g., 2027 volunteers, 2028 volunteers, students), and what each group sees can be controlled — for instance, limiting student volunteers to certain shifts.
  • Volunteer experience & screening: Volunteers can filter by role and location, search for what is closest, or type a site and role. Pre-questions can stop people from registering for shifts they should not take; applicants land in a pending status for review, and ineligible sign-ups can be rejected before they cause confusion. Questions can be asked before and after registration.
  • Cost: $8,000 per year, including SMS texting and other features, on a plan for up to 1,000 volunteers.
  • Follow-up discussion: One participant wanted to track certification level year over year (e.g., 2026 versus 2025) to spot trends. Groups and labels should make that possible, and an automation can add volunteers to a certification group automatically whenever they meet the trigger, so nobody tags each person manually. The automations weren’t all built yet because the focus was on launching. The participant noted their own software keeps adding features that must be relearned each year, with automation buried inside individual events, and that Rosterfy’s approach seemed more logical.
  • Status: Rosterfy had not been live-tested — recruitment was launching the next day — though a couple of tests had gone well. The presenter was optimistic but cautioned that the opinion might change after a full season.

Managing Virtual Volunteers

  • Challenges raised: no manager checking volunteers in and out, tracking remote hours accurately, and having coverage when an intake or quality review call is needed.
  • Approach 1: Experienced volunteers only for virtual tax prep, since a frictionless virtual start can turn new volunteers off; shift times can be looser. A Slack channel assigns volunteers to numbered clients as they move through stages (Contacted, Waiting for Documents, Tax Prepared, QR’d, Ready for transmission), and an open Zoom runs for the whole shift where site managers check in and spot-check Slack statuses.
  • Approach 2: Live Zoom events scheduled in Acuity for both volunteers and clients; volunteers are asked for about 8 shifts from a roughly 44-shift schedule, and client appointments are released based on who signs up. For Get Your Refund, very experienced volunteers handle intake and quality review over Zoom using canned responses and shared Zoom accounts; clients book a 15-minute intake interview, then volunteers prepare asynchronously. Progress is tracked in a spreadsheet, since the stages in Get Your Refund make follow-up hard to see.
  • A program with fully virtual options was offered to be a referral partner for volunteers who want flexible, ad hoc opportunities that fixed-schedule programs can’t accommodate; contact details were shared in chat.

Linking to Client Scheduling

  • Two programs are walk-in only (one is piloting appointments on Sundays at a couple of sites; the other found appointments don’t fit its client base and is trying an RSVP model, where heavy RSVPs let staff suggest another day). One program uses Waitwhile and mostly appointment-only sites, accepting no-shows to avoid long walk-in waits. The facilitator moved from walk-in only to appointments as tools became easier, with reminders.
  • Notes from the earlier appointment scheduling software discussion (September 2) are posted on VITAquality.org: Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes (9/2/26)
  • A participant asked whether DaySmart handles both client and volunteer scheduling; no one knew.

Other Items

  • Has anyone seen the updated Pub 5451 (Volunteer Orientation Guide)? One team has mostly been looking at 1040 changes and the new public charge guidance.
  • Two attendees said RAISE Texas was a great chance to see a large operation and meet people. One participant observed that every system seems to need some adjustment — there is no perfect fit.
  • Prosperity Now VITA grant cohorts were expected to be announced before VITACon; this was not confirmed. Many applied, since last year’s applications were rolled over.
  • VITACon is next week. Because of travel and a personal conflict, the facilitator may cancel the next meeting and will give early notice. A backup facilitator is being considered so the conversation can continue when he is unavailable.

The Society for Free Tax Assistance  •  VITAquality.org  •  a project of JC Craig Consulting

Society for Free Tax Assistance: VITA Meet-up Notes

Date: September 23, 2026

Topic: Quality review — reviewer tools and support, and the taxpayer’s experience of return review

Session Overview

  • Open-floor “what’s on your mind” discussion, followed by the planned topic: the taxpayer’s experience of return review and the tools reviewers use beyond IRS-provided materials.
  • Notes are generated with AI assistance and anonymized before publishing — participant names and identifying program details are left out. Products and public resources mentioned by name are kept in for reference.

What’s on Your Mind

  • Grants: A participant asked whether anyone had news of the VITA-support grant from Wells Fargo, separate from the Citi Foundation child savings support grants that Prosperity Now had just announced. Another participant noted the Wells Fargo announcement is not due until September 29th; the facilitator agreed announcements are getting close.
  • Certifying Acceptance Agents (CAA): The facilitator was asked for suggestions for people pursuing CAA status. A participant noted the IRS is no longer offering forensic document training; the outside provider their program used cost roughly $150. The facilitator encouraged everyone to consider becoming a CAA — assisting with the ITIN application is a major benefit to taxpayers who need it, and many paid preparers charge quite a bit for it. Taxpayers may also struggle to use Taxpayer Assistance Center offices, which can involve ID requirements to enter the building and offices located in buildings that also house immigration enforcement. Taxpayers trust their VITA preparers, and being able to get this help from them is a comfort.
  • Proposed IRS regulation: The facilitator flagged new regulations published in the Federal Register that change requirements for immigrant taxpayers claiming credits — only the refundable portion of a credit would be affected, and eligibility would no longer rest on a work-eligible Social Security card. Their concern is less the taxpayers who lose eligibility than the many who remain eligible but must now sort out how public-charge and public-benefit rules apply, leaving preparers unsure how much to rely on a taxpayer’s own assurances under due diligence. The facilitator views this as poor tax administration, noted the IRS lacks a strong enforcement mechanism (so honest, confused taxpayers are likelier to lose credits than those who would cheat anyway), and said the effort would be better spent on unscrupulous preparers and identity theft.
  • Commenting: Anyone can comment to the Federal Register; comments are due October 5th and can be short (for example, a VITA preparer’s view that they joined to keep people tax compliant, not to determine immigration status). A participant noted long comments may intimidate some volunteers. The facilitator will share their own comments with the listserv and likely post them on VITAQuality.org, and others are free to reuse any of it. The facilitator also noted that VITA volunteers are not currently subject to the paid-preparer EITC due diligence requirements, including the associated form.

Tools Reviewers Use Beyond IRS Materials

  • One program developed a quality review desk guide, rolled out last year, aimed at newer reviewers. Long-time volunteers and managers considered it a waste of time, so the program clarified it is not written for them and does slow things down, but believes it has helped get new reviewers up to speed. The same program also borrowed another program’s self-employment worksheet.
  • The facilitator observed that VITA programs freely borrow and iterate on each other’s materials — sometimes finding a heavily improved version of something they wrote years ago — which is a key reason for keeping this community going. Checklists remain useful even for experienced reviewers, particularly at the start of the season.
  • A quality review training video series created some years ago (role-play style, originally built for an online training and later posted to YouTube by Prosperity Now) may still be available; the facilitator will try to track it down, while noting it is dated.
  • Tax Roundtable was named as a strong resource for complex questions. In a large metro program with highly credentialed volunteers, the facilitator noted the trade-off that experts unfamiliar with low-income returns can find them a new experience.

How Reviewers Get Questions Answered

  • The facilitator described larger sites with a group of reviewers plus a lead reviewer, sometimes on-site and sometimes reachable by phone. Historically, hard questions were pulled in to experienced preparers while the return was put on hold, and questions from remote sites came by phone or email chain.
  • One program tried a person dedicated solely to quality review this past season to keep clients moving in and out on time. That person may be an experienced preparer or the site coordinator, rotating between preparers as needed. The program uses both peer review and designated reviewers depending on site size and appointment slots. Another participant’s site coordinators are all experienced past preparers, so peer review is less of a concern.
  • The facilitator prefers designated reviewers because reviewers improve with repetition, but has not seen strong evidence that designated review beats peer review; many reviewers also want to prepare returns, and review must not become a bottleneck, since bottlenecks lead volunteers to work around the process.
  • Ideas for connecting people: a program wiki, a group chat or Slack-type channel for site coordinators (the facilitator noted having tried Slack too early and being against it at first), and other ways to reach experienced volunteers when a site is out of sight and has a question.

The Taxpayer’s Experience of Review

  • Participants reported that taxpayers are generally very happy that two people look at every return, especially when a reviewer catches something a preparer missed. One participant noted some returning clients ask not to work with a new preparer; they reassure clients that preparers are trained and certified and that help is nearby. This participant has not seen clients upset over a change during review in five years.
  • The facilitator said clients often glaze over during the process, that setting expectations about what happens and why is the main lever, and that VITA accuracy on EITC returns is far better than other preparers’ because of its focus on getting it right and its 100% quality review. Taxpayers themselves are important to review: most mistakes the facilitator has caught surfaced when a taxpayer answered a question differently than the preparer had recorded (for example, a full-time student living in the home who was missing from the intake sheet).
  • Refund display: The facilitator asked whether the running refund amount can be hidden in TaxSlayer; a participant was unsure how. One program seats clients across the table from the screen and withholds the refund number until quality review is complete, so clients aren’t disappointed if it changes. The facilitator dislikes watching taxpayers swing between excited and discouraged as the return is built, but likes clients seeing the screen to catch misspelled names.

Looking Ahead

  • Next session: volunteer management software. Two people are already scheduled to share their experiences, and a third presenter is welcome — Volunteer Hub, Volgistics, and Salesforce were named as common products. A key question is how large or complex a program must be to justify switching from a spreadsheet, since these systems take more technical skill to operate.
  • The facilitator thanked everyone for the strong turnout and will follow up with a participant about volunteer management software contacts.

The Society for Free Tax Assistance  •  VITAquality.org  •  a project of JC Craig Consulting